FIRSTHAND HISTORY
Were you there?
Share what you remember about this game—the plays, people and details that never reached the box score.
2005 vs. Pope John Paul II
The first game after Greenbrier’s 2004 state-final run came on the road against Pope John Paul II. Contemporary coverage framed the night around a young offensive line and a large group of new starters trying to step out of the previous team’s shadow.
The Knights struck immediately on an 86-yard opening kickoff return, but Greenbrier blocked the extra point. The Bobcats answered twice — Justin Pigg scored on the ground and Kyle Herndon later finished a third-quarter drive with a 1-yard touchdown — before Pope John Paul II recovered to win 20–12. The loss opened a season that would ultimately turn into a region championship.
Highlights discussed the next day
On August 20, 2005, the schoolsportsradio.com account advertised highlights of this game, signing the post “Dean.” A reader, dhack, replied that he had watched the footage in RealPlayer. This documents a separate highlights package from the full-game film linked on this page; that original highlights file has not been located.
video source
Opener discussion quickly became a debate about how Greenbrier should replace the 2004 skill production.
Read the exact CoachT post →Game materials
See the full matchup history.
Through 2025, Greenbrier has met Pope John Paul II 4 times, with a series record of 2–2. Open the opponent page for every meeting, then return to this season or Football History.
Open the contemporary game source · 2005 season and source comparison.